Download Ebook Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham
Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham. Give us 5 minutes and we will certainly reveal you the very best book to review today. This is it, the Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham that will certainly be your finest choice for better reading book. Your 5 times will certainly not spend thrown away by reading this website. You can take guide as a resource making much better idea. Referring guides Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham that can be situated with your needs is at some point tough. Yet right here, this is so easy. You can find the very best thing of book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham that you can review.
Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham
Download Ebook Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham
Just how a suggestion can be obtained? By looking at the superstars? By seeing the sea and also looking at the sea weaves? Or by reviewing a book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham Everybody will certainly have certain unique to obtain the motivation. For you which are dying of publications and always obtain the motivations from publications, it is really wonderful to be here. We will certainly reveal you hundreds collections of the book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham to review. If you such as this Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham, you could likewise take it as your own.
Why must be this book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham to read? You will certainly never get the expertise and encounter without managing yourself there or trying by yourself to do it. For this reason, reading this e-book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham is needed. You could be great and also correct enough to get exactly how crucial is reviewing this Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham Even you constantly review by responsibility, you could sustain on your own to have reading book routine. It will certainly be so beneficial and also enjoyable then.
However, how is the means to get this e-book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham Still perplexed? It matters not. You can delight in reading this book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham by on the internet or soft file. Simply download and install the e-book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham in the link given to visit. You will obtain this Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham by online. After downloading, you could conserve the soft documents in your computer or kitchen appliance. So, it will alleviate you to review this publication Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham in certain time or place. It could be not exactly sure to take pleasure in reviewing this book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham, because you have bunches of task. But, with this soft file, you can enjoy reading in the leisure even in the voids of your jobs in workplace.
Again, reviewing behavior will always offer beneficial advantages for you. You could not require to invest many times to check out guide Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham Merely reserved a number of times in our spare or spare times while having meal or in your workplace to review. This Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham will reveal you new point that you can do now. It will assist you to improve the top quality of your life. Occasion it is just an enjoyable e-book Hiroshima Nagasaki, By Paul Ham, you can be happier and also a lot more fun to take pleasure in reading.
The atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki killed more than 100,000 instantly, mostly women, children and the elderly. Many hundreds of thousands more succumbed to their horrific injuries later, or slowly perished of radiation-related sickness. Yet the bombs were "our least abhorrent choice," American leaders claimed at the time―and still today most people believe they ended the Pacific War and saved millions of American and Japanese lives.
Ham challenges this view, arguing that the bombings, when Japan was on its knees, were the culmination of a strategic Allied air war on enemy civilians that began in Germany and had till then exacted its most horrific death tolls in Dresden and Tokyo.
He gives powerful witness to the bomb’s destruction through the eyes of eighty survivors, from 12-year-olds forced to work in war factories to wives and children who faced it alone, reminding us that these two cities were full of ordinary people who suddenly, out of a clear blue summer's sky, felt the sun fall on their heads.
- Sales Rank: #4194935 in Books
- Published on: 2012-08-06
- Formats: Audiobook, MP3 Audio, Unabridged
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 2
- Dimensions: 6.75" h x .68" w x 5.25" l, .20 pounds
- Running time: 21 Hours
- Binding: MP3 CD
From Booklist
*Starred Review* In 1945, in the midst of secrecy about the development of the atomic bomb and ongoing debates over the most “efficient” way to end the war with Japan, American leaders made the fateful decision to launch nuclear attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The bombings certainly stopped the war and destroyed its targeted cities, killing more than 100,000 people, but had they been necessary? Ham presents a forceful argument that the bombing was excessive and unjustified. Alternate chapters recount the building tension toward the awful decision by the Allies and the day-to-day lives of starving Japanese caught between their aggressive emperor and military and sure retaliation. In this sweeping and comprehensive history, Ham details the geopolitical considerations and huge egos behind evolving theories of warfare, the burgeoning killing technology of biological and nuclear war on the part of the Japanese and the Allies as well as the shameful tactic of dehumanizing the Japanese enemy. But most powerful are the eyewitness accounts of 80 survivors, ordinary people caught up in the events of war, who felt the terrible destruction of a nuclear blast and its aftermath of radiation sickness. --Vanessa Bush
Review
“Ham's 629-page volume shows familiarity with much of the literature and debates within historiography, skillfully uses some archival research, and ranges widely in political, diplomatic, and military history… Ham is a splendid storyteller, a master of engrossing and exciting narrative. …[he] digs deeper, and brings back to life the figures who dominated this history, in a page-turner that could reach a wide audience.” ―Los Angeles Review of Books
“Ham presents a forceful argument that the bombing was excessive and unjustified… In this sweeping and comprehensive history, Ham details the geopolitical considerations and huge egos behind evolving theories of warfare… But most powerful are the eyewitness accounts of 80 survivors, ordinary people caught up in the events of war.” ―Booklist (starred review)
“Moral anger drives Mr. Ham… He shows us in agonizing detail that many were maimed or killed… Ordinary Japanese, Mr. Ham believes, were less emperor-worshiping fanatics than victims of an authoritarian elite that prolonged the war with no regard for their hardships.” ―The Wall Street Journal Book Review
“A provocative look at the closing days of the Japanese Empire and the long shadow cast ever after by the atomic bomb….A valuable contribution to the literature of World War II that asks its readers to rethink much of what they've been taught about America's just cause.” ―Kirkus Reviews
“An absorbing read and thoroughly researched work, it is a must-read for those interested in the mortal aspects of total war and military strategy in general. Ham's work will be cited as an important addition to a debate that continues 70 years after the event.” ―Publishers Weekly
“[A] vivid, comprehensive, and quietly furious account . . . Paul Ham brings new tools to the job, unearthing fresh evidence of a deeply disturbing sort. He has a magpie eye for the telling detail.” ―Ben Macintyre, The Times (UK)
“Comprehensive and horrifying.” ―Jonathan Mirsky, Literary Review (UK)
“Provocative and challenging . . . A voice that is both vigorous and passionate.” ―Christopher Sylvester, Daily Express (UK)
“An eyewitness picture that leaves Dante's Inferno looking pale . . . Well documented and stringently argued.” ―Peter Lewis, Daily Mail (UK)
“A provocative reassessment . . . Ham writes with anger and a journalist's eye.” ―The Daily Telegraph (UK)
“With more detail than the average textbook yet written in a way that pulls you in . . . this is essential for anyone remotely interested in . . . history.” ―The Sunday Telegraph (Australia)
“In his comprehensive narrative [Ham] explores the history of the two blasts with considerable skill.” ―Josh Glancy, The Sunday Times (UK)
About the Author
PAUL�HAM�is a historian, specializing in twentieth-century conflict. He is the author of several histories, including the highly acclaimed Kokoda, Vietnam: The Australian War, Hiroshima Nagasaki, Sandakan and 1914: The Year the World Ended. A former journalist and publisher, he has worked for the Financial Times Group and was the Australia correspondent for The Sunday Times of London for fifteen years. Paul was born in Australia and educated in Sydney and London. He now lives in Paris with his family.
Most helpful customer reviews
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Brilliantly done!
By Leo Hindery, Jr.
Brilliantly done. A must-read for any history buff and anyone interested in the issue of nuclear arms and disarmament.
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful.
An Important and Interesting Book; with Caveats
By Theodore F. Schaaf
This is an important book on the Manhattan Program, the atomic bomb attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the surrender of Japan and the aftermath of the bombings.
However, think the author has a bias that dropping the atomic bombs did not contribute to the ending of the war. Am not convinced that this is correct. He asserts that Truman would not have authorized the invasion of Japan. He said that this is the consensus view; but, this is not clear from the text or the footnotes. Also, he pointed out that the atomic bombs had less influence on Japanese leaders than the rapid Russian advances. This is probably true for the army generals, who were clearly very narrow minded. Not so clear for Hirohito, who had some scientific credentials and appears to have a much broader view of the world.
The book gives quite a few examples the self delusion and incompetence of the Japanese government, which could have contributed to the continuation of the war.
It is not clear to me, that Japan would have quickly surrendered without the atomic bombs. If not, the alternatives are likely to have been much worse than the A-bombs. If the war had lasted even another three months, how many millions of Japanese would have starved to death or died in a Soviet invasion of Hokkaido or a US invasion of Kyushu. Not to mention deaths in China and South East Asia.
The horror of the atomic bombings allowed the Japanese people to cast themselves as the victims of WWII. This has kept Japan from facing up to the many criminal acts of their own government. The Japanese people were victims; but, of their own government and army.
135 of 181 people found the following review helpful.
Denial of historical fact for the apparent sake of controversy destroys the value of this book
By James Bowen
"Hiroshima Nagasaki" is a lightweight treatment by prolific journalist author Paul Ham of a very complex issue, namely, the strategic and moral justifications for dropping atomic bombs on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in early August 1945. Six days after the dropping of the second atomic bomb on Nagasaki, the Japanese surrendered.
The justification for the dropping of atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki is likely to be disputed indefinitely. Possibly spurred by the need to promote book sales by creating controversy, Ham makes the extraordinary claim in this book that "not a shred of evidence supports the contention that the Japanese leadership surrendered in direct response to the atomic bombs". On the established historical evidence, it is reasonably clear that two factors were decisive in producing the Japanese surrender. The first was the decision of the Soviet Union to declare war on Japan on 8 August 1945. The second was the face-saving opportunity presented by the dropping of the atomic bombs. Neither factor can be simply swept under the carpet, as Ham does with the atomic bombs. By doing so, Ham destroys any historical value that this book might otherwise have possessed. With the 70th anniversary of the dropping of the atomic bombs occurring in August 2015, and the likelihood of this book being used as another club to belt the United States, I believe that Ham's book requires closer analysis than it has been receiving from some of Ham's adoring but historically challenged fans.
Let me briefly outline the strategic situation at the time when the atomic bombs were dropped. By July 1945, Japan's military and industrial resources had either been destroyed or dispersed widely and largely concealed from air attack. The Americans were finding it very difficult to locate sizeable military or industrial targets for their B-29 bombers to attack with conventional bombs.
In April 1945, the Japanese Suzuki government had prepared a war policy called Ketsugo which was a refinement of the Shosango victory plan for the defence of the home islands to the last man, woman and child. These plans would prepare the Japanese people psychologically to die as a nation in defence of their homeland. Even children, including girls, would be trained to use makeshift lethal weapons, and exhorted to sacrifice themselves by killing an American invader. To implement this policy of training children to kill, soldiers attended Japanese schools and trained even small children in the use of weapons such as bamboo spears.
The American government was aware from intelligence intercepts of the chilling implications of these Japanese defensive plans. Intelligence reports indicated that the Japanese would probably be able to muster two million troops and between six to eight thousand aircraft of all types for the defence of the four home islands against a traditional amphibious invasion. The dispersal of these military resources across Japan, and their careful concealment, would provide the Americans with no opportunity to destroy them from the air. The Ketsugo policy placed heavy reliance on suicide attacks on American troops and their covering warships. For this purpose, several thousand aircraft would be adapted as flying bombs for suicide attacks. Many of these Japanese aircraft to be used in kamikaze attacks would not be front-line aircraft, but they did not need to be for kamikaze flying bomb attacks. The Japanese worked on the basis that kamikaze attacks were justified if one in five manned flying bombs reached the intended target. Other methods of suicide attack being developed included dynamite-filled "crash boats", human-guided torpedoes, manned rocket-powered flying bombs (similar to the "Baka" rocket plane used against American ships at Okinawa), and specially trained ground suicide units carrying explosives. In addition, the invading Americans would have to face a civilian population drilled in guerrilla tactics.
The Americans had every reason to be deeply disturbed when they learned about Japanese plans to defend the home islands by massive suicide attacks on American amphibious forces. The kamikaze suicide attacks on Allied ships at Okinawa had alone produced a horrifying toll: 34 Allied warships sunk ; 368 Allied ships damaged (some fit only for scrap); 4,900 Allied sailors killed; and 4,874 Allied sailors wounded.
The American government would also have been aware in early 1945 that Japan possessed an arsenal of deadly chemical and biological weapons of mass destruction that it had been developing and using against Chinese troops and civilians since Japan initiated its unprovoked and brutal war against China in 1937. Despite the extraordinary secrecy surrounding American acquisition of Japan's very advanced chemical and biological warfare technology after the surrender, we know that American General Joseph Stillwell had been Chief of Staff to Chinese leader Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek and that General Douglas MacArthur provided Japan's chemical and biological warfare military scientists with immunity from prosecution as war criminals in return for their deadly secrets being turned over to the American Army. Unleashed on unprotected American invasion troops on Okinawa, Japan's chemical and biological weapons would have caused massive American casualties. Although acknowledging Japan's use of ghastly chemical and biological warfare weapons against the Chinese, Ham provides more evidence of the lightness of his research when he offers the following absurd, and wholly unsupported, opinion in an endnote:
"The Allies would not learn the extent of Japan's biological warfare capability - that it planned the mass production of cholera, typhoid and paratyphoid bacilli weapons, and had conducted experiments on human beings, mostly Chinese - until after the war".
On 26 July 1945, the Allies issued the Potsdam Declaration. Its purpose was to hasten Japan's surrender without the need for a difficult and very costly amphibious assault on the Japanese home islands. The declaration warned Japan that it faced "prompt and utter destruction" unless the Japanese swiftly agreed to an unconditional surrender. On July 28, Prime Minister Suzuki announced that Japan intended to "ignore" the Potsdam Declaration. Underlying Suzuki's rejection of the Potsdam Declaration was Emperor Hirohito's stubborn resolve to continue the war until he received a guarantee from the Allies that his status as emperor would be preserved and that he would not be tried as a war criminal. There is no evidence that Hirohito felt any genuine concern for the suffering of Japanese civilians as the war encroached on their lives. See the Pulitzer Prize-winning Hirohito and the Making of Modern Japan (2000) by historian and Japan scholar Professor Paul Bix, and especially, the chapter "Delayed Surrender".
When informed that Japan intended to ignore the Potsdam Declaration, President Truman was faced with a dilemma. There was little scope for further conventional bombing. He was left with the choice of ordering an invasion of Japan's home islands or using the atomic bomb. Rather than risk the predicted 1,000,000 American battle casualties in an amphibious assault on Japan, President Truman elected to use the atomic bomb. There can be no doubt that the American public would have chosen the atomic bomb in 1945 rather than one million American casualties. Paul Ham attempts to counter this argument by claiming that American military leaders had predicted only 31,000 casualties in the first 30 days following an amphibious invasion of Japan's home islands. This is an absurd argument. The first Allied amphibious landing was expected to be on the defended shores of the smaller southern home island of Kyushu. Based on massive American casualties incurred over eighty-two days in capturing tiny Okinawa, it is quite possible that the 31,000 Allied casualties would occur on that smaller home island Kyushu alone, and possibly, in the first thirty days; but there were three more home islands still to be captured, including the largest home island Honshu.
In deciding to use the atomic bombs to save as many as a million American casualties, President Truman was entitled to weigh the grave risk that a country prepared to fight to the last man, woman, and child would also be prepared to unleash deadly chemical and bacterial weapons on American troops. Is it so difficult for a journalist like Paul Ham to research adequately the reasons that must have weighed heavily on President Harry Truman's mind when he decided to use the atomic bomb on a recalcitrant Japan in August 1945. I could find no mention of Japan's Ketsugo or Shosango victory plans in Ham's lightweight treatment of the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Following Prime Minister Suzuki's rejection of the Potsdam Declaration, the first target was Hiroshima, a city on Japan's Inland Sea. At this time, Hiroshima was the headquarters of Japan's 2nd General Army. On 4 August 1945, American aircraft dropped leaflets on Hiroshima warning the citizens to expect terrible destruction to be visited upon their city because Japan had refused to surrender. Although many civilians had already been evacuated to the country, this warning was largely ignored. On August 6, the first atomic bomb was dropped on this city. At Hiroshima, 60,000 Japanese died and a similar number were injured.
The emotive impact of the use of an atomic bomb on a Japanese city, and its usefulness as a stick with which to beat the United States, has caused many people to ignore the fact that more people died in the conventional bomb attack on Tokyo on the night of 8/9 March 1945. At Tokyo, on this one night, the bombs and resulting firestorm killed 80,000 people and injured 44,000.
On the evening of 8 August 1945, the Soviet Union declared war on Japan and on 9 August Soviet troops invaded the Japanese puppet state Manchukuo.
On 9 August 1945, when the first atomic bomb had evoked no response from Japan, a second bomb was dropped on Nagasaki, a port with naval installations. The primary target on this day had been the city of Kokura where a huge army arsenal was located. Thick clouds over Kokura forced diversion of the B-29 with the second bomb to Nagasaki. At Nagasaki, 36,000 were killed and about 60,000 wounded.
The combined shock of these events caused Emperor Hirohito to intervene as commander-in-chief of the Japanese military and order the Supreme Council for the Direction of the War, also known as "The Big Six", to accept the terms for ending the war that the Allies had stipulated in the Potsdam Declaration. "The Big Six" were the Prime Minister, Minister for Foreign Affairs, Ministers of War and Navy, and Chiefs of Army and Navy General Staffs. After six more days of behind-the-scenes negotiations and a failed army initiated coup d'etat, Hirohito gave a recorded radio address to the nation on August 15. In the radio address, called the Gyokuon-ho ("Jewel Voice Broadcast"), he announced the effective surrender of Japan, although he did not use the word "surrender". Ham is directly contradicted by Professor Bix in "Hirohito and the making of modern Japan" at page 529. Bix cites the text of the emperor's public broadcast on 15 August 1945, which specifically refers to the destructive power of the atomic bombs in these words "the enemy has begun to employ a new and most cruel bomb" as justification for ending the war. In this speech to the people of Japan, the emperor makes no reference to the Soviet Union having declared war on Japan. In a later and separate speech directed to the Japanese armed forces on 17 August 1945, the emperor makes no reference to the atomic bombs as a reason for ending the war but justifies ending the war on the ground that the Soviet Union has declared war on Japan. So the emperor has very clearly stated that both the atomic bombings and the entry of the Soviet Union into the war justified ending the war. Ham acknowledges that Emperor Hirohito cited in the Gyokuon-ho surrender speech on 15 August the use of "a new and most cruel bomb" by the American enemy as a reason for ending the war but fails to appreciate the illogicality of his claim that the atomic bombs played no part in Japan's surrender.
Professor Bix states that the dropping of the atomic bombs, and the simultaneous entry of the Soviet Union into the war against Japan, were described as "gifts from the gods" by Navy Minister Mitsumasa Yonai (page 509). By mid-1945, Hirohito and his chief political adviser Koichi Kido were becoming increasingly concerned at growing alienation of public support for continuation of the war. District governors and police chiefs were reporting that the Japanese people were war-weary and despondent, and that popular hostility to the emperor and his government was increasing rapidly. Faced with these serious domestic pressures, Hirohito and his councillors welcomed the dropping of the atomic bombs and the Soviet entry into the war as a convenient excuse to accept the terms of the Potsdam Declaration and, at the same time, to provide the emperor with the credit for ending the war (page 523).
Although the casualties from the two atomic bombs are disturbing, they almost certainly represent a very tiny fraction of the Japanese who would have died if the whole population of Japan, civilian as well as military, adults and children, had been mobilised by the Suzuki government to die as a nation in defence of Japan.
The atomic bombs were dropped on two cities of military significance (a) because the Emperor of Japan and his government refused to surrender and were preparing the Japanese people for a fight to the death as a nation, (b) because there were no readily discernible large military or industrial targets available for conventional air attack, and (c) because the Allies faced the prospect of incurring horrendous battle casualties from a conventional amphibious invasion of Japan.
Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham PDF
Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham EPub
Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham Doc
Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham iBooks
Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham rtf
Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham Mobipocket
Hiroshima Nagasaki, by Paul Ham Kindle
No comments:
Post a Comment